Climbing vs. Rambling Roses
Climbing roses have stiff canes, larger flowers, and usually bloom repeatedly through the season. Rambling roses have long, flexible canes, huge clusters of small flowers, and usually bloom once, in early summer. Ramblers grow much larger and are pruned at a different time.
The main differences
- Bloom. Climbers: most repeat from late spring to frost. Ramblers: most flower once, for three to four weeks, in a single overwhelming display.
- Flowers. Climbers: larger, 3 to 5 inches, singly or in small groups. Ramblers: small, 1 to 2 inches, in clusters of dozens.
- Canes. Climbers: thick and fairly stiff. Ramblers: thin, pliable, and very long.
- Size. Climbers: typically 8 to 15 feet. Ramblers: 15 to 30 feet or more.
- Flowering wood. Climbers: flower on new side shoots. Ramblers: flower on canes grown the previous year.
Where each came from
Many climbers are sports, or spontaneous mutations, of bush roses: Climbing Iceberg and Climbing Peace are examples. Others were bred as climbers from the start.
Ramblers descend mainly from two wild species of East Asia, Rosa multiflora and Rosa wichuraiana. Most were raised between about 1890 and 1930, the period that produced Dorothy Perkins, American Pillar, and Albertine.
How pruning differs
This is where confusing the two causes trouble.
- Climbers are pruned in late winter. Keep the main canes and shorten the side shoots to two or three buds.
- Ramblers are pruned just after flowering, in summer. Cut some of the canes that have flowered to the ground, and tie in the new canes growing from the base; these will carry next year's bloom.
Pruning a rambler in late winter removes the wood that was about to flower. See how to prune climbing roses.
Where to use each
Use a climber on an arch, a pergola post, a 6-foot fence, or a house wall. Its size is manageable, and it gives flowers all season.
Use a rambler where there is room for it to run: over a large pergola, along a long fence, up into a mature tree, or over an outbuilding. Its flexible canes drape and weave in a way stiff climbers cannot. For three weeks, nothing else in the garden compares.
Exceptions
A few ramblers repeat, including Super Dorothy, Phyllis Bide, and Ghislaine de Feligonde. A few climbers flower only once. The distinction between the classes is a general one, and catalogs do not always apply the names consistently.
Which to choose
For most gardens, a repeat-flowering climber is the practical choice. Choose a rambler if you have the space, a structure large enough, and the patience to wait eleven months for the show.