Rose BushesA Grower's Guide to Roses
Browse · Trials

Earth-Kind Roses

Earth-Kind is a designation given by Texas A&M AgriLife Extension to roses that performed well in multi-year trials with no fungicide, no insecticide, no fertilizer after planting, and very little water. These are the Earth-Kind roses in the catalog.

How the trials work

Researchers plant candidate roses in replicated field trials, in unimproved soil, and then largely leave them alone. The plants are not sprayed, not fed, not pruned beyond removing dead wood, and are watered only enough to establish them. After several years, only the varieties that stayed healthy and flowered well are given the Earth-Kind name.

What kinds of roses pass

The list surprises people who expect modern roses to dominate. Many Earth-Kind roses are old Tea, China, and polyantha roses that had survived for a century in Southern cemeteries and farmyards. Others, such as Belinda's Dream and Carefree Beauty, are 20th-century shrubs bred for hardiness. The original Knock Out is on the list as well.

Who should grow them

Earth-Kind roses are the safest choice for hot, humid gardens in the South, where black spot defeats most hybrid teas. Several, including the Teas, are hardy only to zone 7. The trials were run in Texas, so the designation tells you most about performance in heat. Gardeners in the North should check each rose's zone rating first.

All 9 roses on this list

RoseClassColorBloomFragranceZones
Belinda's DreamShrubPinkRepeatStrong5-9
Caldwell PinkOld GardenPinkRepeatMild5-9
Climbing PinkieClimbingPinkRepeatMild6-9
Souvenir de St. Anne'sOld GardenPale pinkRepeatModerate6-9
DucherOld GardenWhiteRepeatModerate7-10
Monsieur TillierOld GardenPink/copper orangeRepeatModerate7-10
Mrs. Dudley CrossOld GardenYellow/pinkRepeatMild7-10
Madame Antoine MariOld GardenPinkRepeatModerate7-10
Georgetown TeaOld GardenSalmon pinkRepeatModerate7-10